There has been tension between President Trump and the Federal Reserve / Fed Chairman Powell this year as Trump has been publicly pressuring the Federal Reserve to lower interest rates.

For context, the Federal Reserve has historically eased monetary policy to combat a slowing economy / recession, increase employment and / or increase inflation if they feel inflation is too low.

FYI, it appears the Fed is preparing to cut rates at its next meeting in a couple weeks. So today’s commentary is more of a theoretical discussion.

Based on the criteria above, should the Federal Reserve be lowering interest rates? Probably not yet. Unemployment is quite low at around 4.2%, inflation remains above the Fed’s target as it has been for over four years now, the stock market is near all-time highs, and the economy is growing based on the most recent report. Although, last month’s jobs report was very weak and there are some leading indicators reflecting weakness.

Perhaps the real reason President Trump is pressuring the Fed to lower interest rates is because the U.S. Government has to refinance trillions of treasury debt maturing over the next couple years and refinancing at current rates would increase interest expense and further strain the federal budget. More on this below…

 

The Fed deserves some criticism. The Fed is supposed to be strictly independent of politics and should apply their methodologies consistently regardless of who is in office or where pressure may be coming from. After all, every President would want the Fed to ease monetary conditions to make the economy look better even if temporarily. This is why we don’t grant the Executive and Legislative branches the power over monetary policy.

The Fed brought this criticism upon itself by lowering interest rates last year during election season when the metrics were essentially the same as they are now. This gives the appearance the Fed was trying to boost economic metrics leading into the election, which would obviously have helped the incumbent / incumbent’s party.

If they were to apply their methodologies consistently they would either not have eased last year or would have continued cutting rates this year. But by cutting rates last year and (appropriately) refusing to do so this year, they appear biased and political, which would be a severe violation of their independence and the public’s trust.

 

One of the reasons I suspect Trump wants the Fed to lower interest rates is because our country has a wall of Treasury debt maturing over the next couple years that will need to be refinanced at prevailing interest rates so he wants interest rates as low as possible so that debt can be refinanced cheaply.

For fiscal year 2024, net interest payments amounted to ~$900 billion and projected to be about $1 trillion for FY2025!

It is estimated we have $7.6 trillion coming due over the next year and more than double that over the next several years. That’s all debt that will need to be refinanced at prevailing interest rates.

Now, imagine an average 5% interest rate on all $40 trillion of outstanding debt…that would be $2 trillion of annual interest payments alone!

However, it is critical that the Federal Reserve remain strictly independent of politicians’ whims and desires. Otherwise, the problem is obvious…every administration would want low interest rates to make the economy look better and reduce the need for spending cuts / tax increases thereby leading to runaway inflation.

Politicians have a history of being reckless, irresponsible, and wasteful, which is clearly evident by the fact that our national debt is nearly $40 trillion debt (120% of GDP!), and our government continues to run multi-trillion annual deficits.

It does not matter which political party is in control, deficits pile on and the debt continues to grow with no end in sight. They seem unable to make even the smallest cuts to annual spending.

High interest costs is the market’s way of forcing politicians to make necessary change as inconvenient as it may be. But by artificially lowering interest rates it further delays administration of the “cure” while simultaneously providing a short-term painkiller thereby causing the “patient” to get sicker while temporarily masking the symptoms.

The Federal Reserve does not exist to subsidize politicians’ reckless policies and spending. The Federal Reserve exists to be a lender of last resort in a crisis, promote maximum employment and maintain price stability. It’s imperative our politicians address the deficit, while the Fed remain strictly independent and focus only on its mandate.