Many have been surprised at how steady inflation has been this year (not “low” per se but “steady”). The expectation was that consumer prices would rise meaningfully in response to the current Administration’s tariffs / trade policy. 

Instead, inflation has remained relatively steady over the year as illustrated in the chart below.

Even Fed Chairman Jerome Powell acknowledges, in the short video snippet shared below, his surprise and provides a reason why tariffs have not (at least so far) had a meaningful impact on consumer prices.

Click on image to play snippet…

Source: WSJ News, September 23, 2025 @ https://youtu.be/QaRB8NnGYVU?si=04Kr0-iWEgcykeO4

 

The Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco recently published a paper where they concluded tariffs historically have, surprisingly, resulted in lower inflation but higher unemployment (lower economic activity). They came to this conclusion after studying 150 years of tariff shocks across the U.S., the UK and France.

They conclude the reason for this is lower economic activity resulting from tariff shocks. In other words, tariff shocks act through “an aggregate demand channel.”

They acknowledge the result “goes against the predictions of standard models, whereby CPI inflation should go up in response to higher tariffs.”

The paper can be found here.

Factors Impacting the Generalized, Aggregate Price Level

My personal view is that it’s very difficult to determine the short-term impact of a policy (such as tariffs) because there are so many factors at play, and it’s very difficult to control every variable while isolating a single one.

In my opinion, as I’ve discussed in the past, there are two factors that impact the generalized price level of a nation (1) the supply of money and (2) the supply of goods.

If the supply of money increases while the supply of goods remains constant, declines or increases slower than the supply of money then you have the conditions for generalized price inflation.

If the supply of money falls while the supply of goods remains constant, falls at a slower rate or increases then the generalized national price level will decline.

If the supply of goods increases while the supply of money remains constant, declines or increases more slowly then prices fall.

If the supply of goods decreases while the supply of money remains constant, falls more slowly, or increases then you have the conditions for generalized price inflation.

And so on…

Even though this is relatively simple (e.g. the supply of money vs. the supply of goods), there are many factors impacting both the supply of money and the supply of goods, which is why it becomes so complicated and difficult to predict inflation in the short-term.

For example, tariffs could temporarily reduce the supply of goods available, which is a potential catalyst for inflation, however, it also depends on what is simultaneously happening to the money supply.

Or, if tariffs have no impact on the supply of goods and the money supply is constant, the price of some goods affected by tariffs could go up, but the prices of other goods would have to go down to compensate for the constant money supply. Therefore, all else equal, there would be no change in the generalized price level.